by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

Post

Region: URA


URA World Assembly Recommendation

Equal Justice Under Law
Cognizant of the recently repealed GAR #374 “The Rule Of Law” that mandated liability and responsibility for the actions and decisions of government officials and institutions of member nations before the law,

Adamant to restore the principles of the rule of law in a manner that truly embodies the spirit of this noble ideal, so as to ensure that this fundamental component of governance will stand firm on pillars of fairness and justice, and will ward off both arbitrary or discriminatory punishment,

The General Assembly hereby:

  1. Defines "legislative immunity" as immunity from prosecution or litigation for actions conducted in the context of legitimate legislative activity such as the casting of votes or the debating of legislation,

  2. Establishes that all private and public individuals, officials, entities, and institutions, as well as the state itself and its administrative and political subdivisions are to be held accountable for the acts and decisions that have been made during the employ, tenure, appointment or existence of the aforementioned. Such accountability shall be under either the national, regional, and/or local laws of member states, where applicable, as well as under any guidelines and/or disciplinary measures that may be in use by a particular organization,

  3. Requires that all member nations have the principles of the supremacy of the law and accountability to the law enshrined in the highest form of their national law,

  4. Clarifies that:

    1. member states may extend legislative immunity to individuals empowered to conduct legislative activity; and that

    2. officials or institutions empowered to do so may carry out acts of clemency such as pardons and commutations, provided that such acts comply with extant or future General Assembly legislation and the spirit of this resolution.

Co-authored with Greater Cesnica.

This General Assembly resolution was written by Daarwyrth and Greater Cesnica to reinforce the rule of law. You can find the forum thread here.

The United Regions Alliance recommends that you vote AGAINST the resolution

This resolution, in support of the principles of the rule of law, requires all individuals and institutions to be held accountable for any actions they take based on all applicable laws in their jurisdiction. Member states are also required to "have the principles of the supremacy of the law and accountability to the law enshrined" in their law. Lastly, this resolution allows the extension of legislative immunity to anyone responsible for conducting "legislative activity" and the issuing of clemency towards people or institutions. The Alliance takes issue with the wording of the final clause of this resolution. Allowing full legal immunity for those involved with vaguely defined "legislative activity" simply enshrines the protection of corrupt politicians under the law. Additionally, lobbying organizations (such as corporations, powerful private individuals, etc.) could be considered to conduct legislative activity, thereby extending such immunity to them as well. For that reason, the URA cannot support this resolution.


The following comments were given on the LinkURA Discord server:

Sonindia voting member Quinceria wrote,

Quinceria wrote:Ah yes. I’m sure this one would never be abused by politicians. Giving people with legislative powers legal immunity will not only allow but breed corruption. Furthermore, the lack of definition of people who participate in legislative activity means that people who aren’t politicians but instead pressure groups which can range from charities to corporations to terrorist groups as an argument can be made that all of these pressure politicians and so do participate in legislative activity.

Mariner Trench voting member Calamari lands wrote,

Calamari lands wrote:Wouldn't reasonable nation theory apply to this? I've seen it mentioned with other resolutions and it'd mean that the WA relies on nations to interpret it in ways that wouldn't go against their interests. And I'm pretty sure legislative immunity is pretty vital to keep democracy working so that a political faction doesn't exploit the law against their opponents.

Lands End voting member TESDAI asked,

TESDAI wrote:Wouldn't the political faction in power be the one's that interpret the WA laws, and therefore be the ones exploiting the laws?

To which Mariner Trench voting member Calamari lands replied,

Calamari lands wrote:I mean exploiting the law in cases like incriminating the opposition of something, which can be done... if they don't have legal immunity. If they do, then they can't be incriminated with the law for political purposes. And as for the "applying it to pressure groups", that's where the reasonable nation argument comes in. Yes, the faction in power is the one interpreting the law, and assuming that they're reasonable and won't work against their own interests, they won't make the definition apply to everything that was mentioned. That way legal immunity is guaranteed so there is no exploitation in that sense, and being reasonable makes it so the definition isn't applied super broadly. I think that makes sense.


This document was authored by Scalizagasti on behalf of the United Regions Alliance. Please do not reproduce it without permission.

Dalek-Empire
Lesser Velutaria
Suvmia
Ktchenia
Gladys and the drowning fish
Duby
Orioni 2
You should see me in a crown
Marlida
J-o-e
TESDAI
Calamari lands
Oi Barbaroi
Seludong
Alentejo and Algarve
Noble titans
New Ziah
Quinceria
Volykos
Draganisia
Orca and Narwhal
The united provinces of north america
Davelands
Highlock
Tuandle
The Independent States of Allied Forces

Read dispatch


URA World Assembly Recommendation

Against Quorum Raiding
The World Assembly,

Defining quorum raiding as the act of unseating delegates approving a World Assembly proposal in order to prevent the approved proposal from reaching quorum and going to vote,

Understanding that historically, quorum raiding was used as an anti-fascist tactic and was used exclusively in order to prevent any subscriber of this particularly vile ideology from promoting themselves or spreading propaganda to the eyes of thousands of world leaders, and billions of people,

Concerned, however, that the practice has evolved beyond that of merely preventing the spread of fascism and similar ideologies, turning into an alternative for counter-campaigning any telegram getting to vote, allowing the opinion of a few to be much more forcefully shot down without any actual consent from the approving delegates,

Believing that quorum raiding undermines the democratic right of the collective delegates of the World Assembly and subjects them to be momentarily dethroned,

Observing that past use of quorum raiding and similar tactics have proven to be harmful to the establishment of the World Assembly and its participants, discouraging many delegates with smaller endorsement counts to abstain altogether from approving proposals out of fear of retaliation, making it significantly harder for proposals to reach vote following instances of quorum raiding,

Noting that using non-combative means of preventing a proposal from going to vote, including but not limited to informative counter-campaigns and outreach, serve to prevent conflict and alleviate tension regarding World Assembly proposals,

Hereby;

  1. Proclaims its unwavering opposition to quorum raiding as an expression of opinion on any individual proposal or author,

  2. Urges militaries to immediately cease quorum raiding operations except in cases where the concerned proposal will serve as a tool for propaganda for any particularly hateful ideology or any region or nation which legitimately adheres to said ideology, and the only regions targeted by the operation are supporters of such an ideology,

  3. Further urges militaries wishing to quorum raid a proposal excepted from clause two to only do so after extensive forethought and as a last resort,

  4. Reminds nations, regardless of actual militaristic ideology, to remember that the World Assembly as an organization should not suffer due to personal political ambitions of any one individual, nation, region, or other organization, regardless of the adherence to this resolution, and asks them to act with good intentions towards the World Assembly, its inhabitants, and the world at large.

Co-authored by Morover.

This Security Council resolution was written by Jedinsto and Morover to oppose quorum raiding. You can find the forum thread here.

The United Regions Alliance recommends that you vote AGAINST the resolution

This declaration expresses its opposition to the practice of quorum raiding, which this resolution defines as "the act of unseating delegates approving a World Assembly proposal in order to prevent the approved proposal from reaching quorum." The resolution declares that all militaries should cease quorum raiding except as a last resort for preventing hateful propaganda. The Alliance strongly disagrees with these suggestions; limiting the ways in which regional operators can combat fascism in the WA is not a policy to be supported. Leaving quorum raiding as a last resort could allow hateful resolutions to sneak through the queue and enter voting procedures. In its opposition, the URA recommended to its delegates that they should withhold support from this declaration. For these reasons, the URA strongly recommends voting against this resolution.


The following comments were given on the LinkURA Discord server:

St Abbaddon voting member Draganisia wrote,

Draganisia wrote:Well I hate most raiding... Unless it's against Nazis or extreme Communists. I'm 50/50 on this one specifically but overall will vote for it in the poll at least.

Conch Kingdom resident Kursibar wrote,

Kursibar wrote:Oooo, a declaration against quorum raiding, like that will do anything. I like how the SC has been redefined by the Declarations thing. No longer a popularity contest, it's now a weaker, meta GA lol.

Conch Kingdom voting member Duby wrote,

Duby wrote:Declarations don't do crap, so there's no point for having them. If people want and can quorum raid, this won't stop them.

To which Karma voting member You should see me in a crown wrote,

You should see me in a crown wrote:Even if it won't mechanically do anything, I always like to pretend it'll have some kind of ripple effect because playing the game by just what's there is boring as hell!


This document was authored by Scalizagasti on behalf of the United Regions Alliance. Please do not reproduce it without permission.

Dalek-Empire
Lesser Velutaria
Suvmia
Ktchenia
Gladys and the drowning fish
Duby
Orioni 2
You should see me in a crown
Marlida
J-o-e
TESDAI
Calamari lands
Oi Barbaroi
Seludong
Alentejo and Algarve
Noble titans
New Ziah
Quinceria
Volykos
Draganisia
Orca and Narwhal
The united provinces of north america
Davelands
Highlock
Tuandle
The Independent States of Allied Forces

Read dispatch

ContextReport